Select Page

Campaigners already pushing to extend assisted suicide to people without terminal illness

With the assisted suicide Bill set to be voted on at the end of November, campaigners are already pushing to extend assisted suicide to people without terminal illnesses.

Earlier this week, Labour MP Kim Leadbeater tabled her Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill and, while the details of the Bill have not yet been released, the Bill is expected to apply to people with less than six or twelve months left to live. 

However, a leading campaign group and a number of high-profile individuals are not satisfied and are vocal about their wish to see the scope of the Bill widened.

On the same day that Leadbeater tabled her Bill, Humanists UK said that anyone “incurably suffering” should be able to access assistance in suicide.

At the same time, retired judge Sir Nicholas Mostyn, a long-time friend and podcast cohost of assisted suicide campaigner Lord Falconer, lamented the fact that Leadbeater’s Bill would not, in its current expected form, apply to people who were not terminally ill. Sir Nicholas, who has Parkinson’s disease and runs a podcast, Movers and Shakers, about the condition said “There is a cohort of people like us who it is not going to help and we are left with the existing, most unsatisfactory law”.

“Parkies will never get a terminal diagnosis, so this bill is no f***ing use to us at all”.

MPs calling for expansion of assisted suicide Bill

Former NHS England Medical Director Dr Graham Winyard is also calling for Leadbeater’s Bill to include “both the terminally ill and the incurably suffering”. Winyard complained that less than half of UK residents who ended their lives by assisted suicide in Switzerland in recent years would have been eligible for assisted suicide under Leadbeater’s Bill in its current expected form.

Mostyn’s comments come soon after it was revealed that, according to the Telegraph, a group of 54 cross-party MPs are believed to be campaigning for Leadbeater’s assisted suicide Bill to apply not only to people who are terminally ill, but also to those who are “incurably suffering”. These include “as many as 38 Labour” MPs, 13 of whom are in Government positions.

The news that these MPs were backing a more radical change in the law came shortly after Leadbeater insisted that her Bill will only apply to those with terminal illnesses.

Safeguards will not work”

Fears that the law will be expanded and become a threat to disabled and vulnerable people have been shared by opponents of the Bill. Actress and activist Liz Carr, who described the prospect of legalising assisted suicide in the UK as “terrifying” in her BBC documentary Better Off Dead?, shared her fears about its effect on vulnerable people.

She said “For many disabled people the assumption that we’d be ‘Better Off Dead’ is something that we get used to hearing. We do not believe that any safeguard can adequately protect us from coercion, abuse, mistake and discrimination. We believe that if assisted suicide is legalised, disabled, ill and older people risk being devalued to death”.

Baroness Ilora Finlay also expressed concerns about safeguards, saying “You will be told that watertight safeguards can be written into an assisted suicide bill. But how do we define terminal illness? Diagnoses can be wrong and prognoses are notoriously inaccurate. There should be no coercion, but who can really judge this?”. 

In the annual assisted suicide report ‘Oregon Death with Dignity Act: 2023 Data Summary’, among the end-of-life concerns listed by those who ended their lives, almost half (43.3%) of those who ended their lives reported being concerned about being a “[b]urden on family, friends/caregivers”.

Spokesperson for Right To Life UK, Catherine Robinson, said “Alarm bells are rightly ringing at the prospect of this dangerous assisted suicide Bill. Even before the Bill received its First Reading earlier this week, prominent voices were calling for the scope of the Bill to be widened”.

“The UK should heed the warning signs. Residency requirements for assisted suicide in the state of Oregon were recently removed leading to concerns about ‘suicide tourism’, and the interpretation of terminal illness in Oregon has been broadened to include anorexia, arthritis, hernias and diabetes”.

“We are calling on the UK to resist this dark and sinister path and instead to choose life, putting resources into high-quality palliative care”.

URGENT
APPEAL
to protect vulnerable lives

Help stop three major anti-life threats.

Help fight major assisted suicide and abortion up to birth threats.

Dear reader,

Despite the Leadbeater assisted-suicide Bill passing its Third Reading on 20 June, it scraped through by just 23 votes (314-291) after enjoying a 55-vote majority at Second Reading. Had 12 more MPs switched sides, the Bill would be dead. It now limps into the Lords with a wafer-thin majority, where peers can amend, delay or reject it outright.

THE CHALLENGE

Dignity in Dying, My Death My Decision and Humanists UK have poured millions into pushing assisted suicide and will fight hard to stop the Lords overturning the Bill.

At the same time, the Antoniazzi abortion-up-to-birth amendment, passed by MPs in June, also heads to the Lords. If it becomes law, it would no longer be illegal for women to perform their own abortions for any reason – including sex-selective purposes – and at any point up to and during birth.

We will be up against the UK’s largest abortion providers, BPAS and MSI Reproductive Choices (formerly Marie Stopes), who are expected to push for even more extreme changes to our abortion laws in the Lords.

WE NEED YOUR HELP

Thousands of vulnerable lives are now at stake. Battling these two threats is the biggest and most expensive effort in our history, and has drained our limited resources. To fight effectively on both fronts, we aim to raise £200,000 by midnight this Sunday (13 July 2025).

Every donation, large or small, will help protect lives, and UK taxpayers can add 25p to every £1 through Gift Aid at no extra cost.

Will you make a donation now to help protect vulnerable lives from these major threats?

URGENT
APPEAL
to protect vulnerable lives

Help stop three major anti-life threats.

Help fight major assisted suicide and abortion up to birth threats.