All MPs making up Labour’s new shadow cabinet have never voted pro-life on abortion

The new leader of the Labour party Sir Keir Starmer has appointed a shadow cabinet that has never voted pro-life on abortion.

An analysis of 16 votes going back 13 years to 2007 shows that none of 29 MPs handed roles in the shadow cabinet today have voted pro-life on abortion.

A deeper analysis of the results further highlights how out-of-touch the newly formed opposition are with the general public on abortion.

Polling shows that 93% of women support a law banning sex-selective abortion in the UK. However, out of the 15 shadow cabinet MPs who were eligible to vote on banning sex-selective abortion in the UK 11 voted against and 4 abstained.

Similarly, the polling shows that 91% of women in the UK would support a bill that gave women considering abortion a legal right to independent counselling from a source that has no financial interest in her decision. Yet, when the opportunity to support such a change in law arose eleven voted against, 2 abstained and none voted in favour.

In the UK, only 1% of the population support legislation allowing abortion for any reason up to birth. However, the majority of MPs in Labour’s shadow cabinet threw their support behind a 2017 Bill calling for such a change. The Bill introduced by pro-abortion Labour MP Diana Johnson was supported by 16 MPs, with 9 abstaining and none voting against the Bill.

On assisted suicide there is a much more positive picture, with the 29 MPs sharing a mixed voting record. Out of the 23 shadow cabinet MPs eligible to vote when assisted suicide was roundly defeated, in 2015, 11 voted against its introduction while only 6 voted for and a further 6 abstained. 

Despite his poor record on life issues, Sir Keir Starmer won the contest to lead the Labour party on Saturday with fifty-six percent of the vote. 

His election comes after Jeremy Corbyn announced he would step down as Labour leader shortly after losing a fourth general election in a row last year.

The now former Labour leader had pledged to introduce abortion, for any reason, up to birth, but ultimately the party suffered their worst electoral defeat since 1935. 

Unfortunately, it seems neither Sir Keir Starmer or his shadow cabinet are any different.  

Since becoming an MP in 2015, he has voted in support of imposing an extreme abortion regime on Northern Ireland and in favour of assisted suicide.

Ahead of the election, Sir Keir Starmer signed a pledge from the UK’s largest abortion provider, the British Pregnancy Advisory Service, to support a change in law that would introduce abortion for any reason up to birth – the only Labour leadership candidate to have done so.

Additionally, he has thrown his support behind a host of pro-abortion pledges listed in an open letter to his as evidenced through his personal tweet in reply.

Speaking of his new appointments Sir Keir Starmer said: “I’m proud to have appointed a shadow cabinet that showcases the breadth, depth and talents of the Labour Party.

“This is a new team that will be relentlessly focused on acting in the national interest to respond to the coronavirus pandemic and rebuilding Labour so that it can win the next election.”

A spokesperson for Right To Life UK, Catherine Robinson said: 

“The new shadow cabinet continues to show how out of touch the Labour party are with the general public and women on the issue of abortion. 

“Last year, Right To Life UK’s analysis of the 2019 election revealed that the number of pro-life MPs has increased while the pro-abortion lobby has lost a large number of MPs. In the Republic of Ireland all fifteen politicians who voted against legalising abortion kept their seats in the country’s general election while many of the country’s strident pro-abortion members lost their seats. 

“With that in mind we were disappointed to see the Labour Party elect yet another leader who takes an extreme pro-abortion position when it comes to voting on abortion in Parliament and remain disappointed to see this is also the case with the shadow cabinet.

However, we are also hopeful that what appears to be the Labour Party moving back to an overall more centrist position will make it easier for Labour MPs who are pro-life to maintain their position as Labour MPs. Momentum-led local party associations have put an enormous amount of negative pressure on some Labour Party MPs that have taken a pro-life position on life issues. With the election of a non-Momentum candidate as leader, we are hoping that this will signal a slowdown of these extreme elements in the party and that the party will be more open to a variety of views on life issues among its MPs.”

MPRole within cabinetVoting Record
Keir Starmer, Leader of the OppositionLeader of the OppositionSee voting record
Angela RaynerDeputy Leader and Chair of the Labour PartySee voting record
Anneliese DoddsShadow ChancellorSee voting record
Lisa NandyShadow Foreign SecretarySee voting record
Nick Thomas-SymondsShadow Home SecretarySee voting record
Rachel ReevesShadow Chancellor of the Duchy of LancasterSee voting record
David LammyShadow Justice SecretarySee voting record
John HealeyShadow Defence SecretarySee voting record
Ed MilibandShadow Business, Energy and Industrial SecretarySee voting record
Emily ThornberryShadow International Trade SecretarySee voting record
Jonathan ReynoldsShadow Work and Pensions SecretarySee voting record
Jonathan AshworthShadow Secretary of State for Health and Social CareSee voting record
Rebecca Long-BaileyShadow Education SecretarySee voting record
Jo StevensShadow Digital, Culture, Media and Sport SecretarySee voting record
Bridget PhillipsonShadow Chief Secretary to the TreasurySee voting record
Luke PollardShadow Environment, Food and Rural Affairs SecretarySee voting record
Steve ReedShadow Communities and Local Government SecretarySee voting record
Thangam DebbonaireShadow Housing SecretarySee voting record
Jim McMahonShadow Transport SecretarySee voting record
Preet Kaur GillShadow International Development SecretarySee voting record
Louise HaighShadow Northern Ireland Secretary (interim)See voting record
Ian MurrayShadow Scotland SecretarySee voting record
Nia GriffithShadow Wales SecretarySee voting record
Marsha de CordovaShadow Women and Equalities SecretarySee voting record
Andy McDonaldShadow Employment Rights and Protections SecretarySee voting record
Rosena Allin-KhanShadow Minister for Mental HealthSee voting record
Cat SmithShadow Minister for Young People and Voter EngagementSee voting record
Lord FalconerShadow Attorney General--
Valerie VazShadow Leader of the HouseSee voting record
Nick BrownOpposition Chief WhipSee voting record
Baroness SmithShadow Leader of the Lords--
Lord McAvoyLords’ Opposition Chief Whip--

Where does Labour’s new leader Keir Starmer stand on abortion?

Keir Starmer has been announced as the new Labour Party leader with fifty-six percent of the vote. Starmer will be joined by Angela Rayner as deputy leader.

Starmer’s election brings to an end the almost five-year duration of Jeremy Corbyn as leader of the party. After announcing plans to introduce abortion, for any reason, up to birth, Labour suffered their worst electoral defeat since 1935. 

Keir Starmer does not have a good record when it comes to life issues.

In July 2019 he voted in support of imposing an extreme abortion regime on Northern Ireland. In October 2018, he voted in support of an amendment to put pressure on the Government to change abortion legislation in Northern Ireland.

That same month, he voted in support of a Ten-Minute Rule Motion, which if it had been successful, would have introduced abortion on demand, for any reason, up-to 24-weeks in Northern Ireland – along with removing many of the current legal safeguards around abortion provision in England and Wales.

Keir Starmer’s voting record on abortion and assisted suicide.
Sourced from the Where Do They Stand voting record database.


On the assisted suicide issue, he voted in September 2015 in support of a Bill to introduce assisted suicide to England and Wales. That Bill was then defeated by a very large margin (330 votes to 118).

Ahead of the election, he signed a pledge from the UK’s largest abortion provider, the British Pregnancy Advisory Service, to support a change in law that would introduce abortion for any reason up to birth – the only leadership candidate to have done so.

Additionally, he has thrown his support behind a host of pro-abortion pledges listed in an open letter to his as evidenced through his personal tweet in reply.

The pledges include:

  • Introducing abortion up to birth, for any reason to the UK 
  • Opposing any attempt to reduce the abortion time limit
  • Supporting the introduction of buffer zones around all hospitals and clinics providing abortion ‘services’ 
  • Remove the two doctor clause
  • Require doctors to register their conscientious objection
  • Introduce a legal requirement for hospitals to provide abortion ‘services’

Before becoming an MP in 2015, Sir Keir Starmer made some startling revelations over his abortion stance while he was the UK’s Director of Public Prosecutions. 

A month before quitting as the head of the Crown Prosecution Service, Sir Keir ruled against the prosecution of two doctors who were secretly filmed arranging sex-selective abortions in a Telegraph exposé. The CPS stated it was not in the “public interest” to prosecute the individuals. 

In a letter explaining his decision to the Attorney General, Dominic Grieve, Sir Keir said that the 1967 Abortion Act “does not… expressly prohibit gender-specific abortions.” He also noted that in many cases doctors approve abortions without even meeting their patient.

Since then he has also said abortion should not be a “criminal law issue”

Speaking during a visit to a nursery in Batley, West Yorkshire, he said: “It should be a matter of a woman’s right to choose. I want to see this reviewed and changed. We need to take criminal law out of it.”

Starmer will be joined by Angela Rayner as deputy leader. Unfortunately, Rayner has a similarly bad record when it comes to the beginning of life, but appears to take a pro-life position when it comes to the end of life, voting to oppose assisted suicide.

Angela Rayner’s voting record on abortion and assisted suicide.
Sourced from the Where Do They Stand voting record database.

Spokesperson for Right To Life UK, Catherine Robinson said:

“We are disappointed to see the Labour Party elect yet another leader who takes an extreme pro-abortion position when it comes to voting on abortion in Parliament. Keir Starmer has been joined by Angela Rayner, who has a similar bad record when it comes to the abortion issue. Fortunately, she opposed introducing assisted suicide in 2015 and we hope that her opposition to assisted suicide will continue in her new position and that she can be of influence on this issue to Keir Starmer and the rest of the party.

We are also hopeful that what appears to be the Labour Party moving back to an overall more centrist position will make it easier for Labour MPs who are pro-life to maintain their position as Labour MPs. Momentum-led local party associations have put an enormous amount of negative pressure on some Labour Party MPs that have taken a pro-life position on life issues. With the election of a non-Momentum candidate as leader, we are hoping that this will signal a slow down of these extreme elements in the party and that the party will be more open to a variety of views on life issues among its MPs.”

Where do all five Labour leadership candidates stand on abortion?

Abortion is quick becoming an issue in the Labour leadership race, in which five MPs are competing to be named Jeremy Corbyn’s successor on 4 April. 

The current Labour leader is standing down after Labour lost its fourth general election in a row last month.

After announcing plans to introduce abortion, for any reason, up to birth, Labour suffered their worst electoral defeat since 1935. 

The five candidates standing to be the leader of the Labour Party include Sir Keir Starmer, Rebecca Long-Bailey, Lisa Nandy, Jess Philipps and Emily Thornberry. 

Sadly, all five candidates voted in favour of imposing Europe’s most extreme abortion law on Northern Ireland as illustrated in the graphic below.

Issue one: Amendment to impose law change on Northern Ireland to introduce abortion (09-07-2019)
Issue two: Amendment to pressure the Government to change abortion legislation in Northern Ireland (24-10-2018)
Issue three: Introduce abortion on demand, for any reason, up-to 24-weeks in Northern Ireland (23-10-2018)
Issue four: Introduce abortion on demand, for any reason, up-to-birth in England and Wales (13-03-2017)
Issue five: Legalise assisted suicide (11-09-2011)

Additionally, all five candidates have thrown their support behind a host of pro-abortion pledges listed in an open letter to them as evidenced through their personal tweets: Sir Keir Starmer, Rebecca Long-Bailey, Lisa Nandy, Jess Philipps and Emily Thornberry

The pledges include:

  • Introducing abortion up to birth, for any reason to the UK 
  • Opposing any attempt to reduce the abortion time limit
  • Supporting the introduction of buffer zones around all hospitals and clinics providing abortion ‘services’ 
  • Supporting making the ‘morning-after pill’ available for free from pharmacies, including for under 16s
  • Remove the two doctor clause
  • Require doctors to register their conscientious objection
  • Introduce a legal requirement for hospitals to provide abortion ‘services’

The 57-year-old shadow Brexit secretary is, as of writing, the bookmakers’ favourite to become Labour leader and received the most backing in the first stage of the contest, securing 88 nominations. 

However, before becoming an MP in 2015 Sir Keir Starmer made some startling revelations over his abortion stance while he was the UK’s Director of Public Prosecutions. 

A month before quitting as the head of the Crown Prosecution Service, Sir Keir ruled against the prosecution of two doctors who were secretly filmed arranging sex-selective abortions in a Telegraph exposé. The CPS stated it was not in the “public interest” to prosecute the individuals. 

In a letter explaining his decision to the Attorney General, Dominic Grieve, Sir Keir said that the 1967 Abortion Act “does not… expressly prohibit gender-specific abortions.” He also noted that in In many cases doctors approve abortions without even meeting their patient.

Ahead of the election, Sir Keir signed a pledge from the UK’s largest abortion provider, the British Pregnancy Advisory Service, to support a change in law that would introduce abortion for any reason up to birth – the only leadership candidate to have done so.

Since then he has also said abortion should not be a “criminal law issue”

Speaking during a visit to a nursery in Batley, West Yorkshire, he said: “It should be a matter of a woman’s right to choose. I want to see this reviewed and changed. We need to take criminal law out of it.”

Sir Keir voted in favour of Rob Marris’ assisted suicide bill which was roundly rejected by 330 votes to 118, in 2015.

The 40-year-old shadow business secretary received the second-highest number of nominations, with the backing of 33 Labour colleagues. 

Rebecca Long-Bailey was under fire yesterday from Labour party supporters on social media after it was widely reported she does not support disability-selective abortion after the standard limit of 24 weeks. 

Currently, disability-selective abortion, for conditions including Down’s syndrome, cleft lip and club foot up to birth, is legal for any reason up to birth while the upper limit is 24 weeks if there is no disability. 

However, since then, a spokesman for Long-Bailey has ‘stressed’ to the Guardian that she “unequivocally supports a woman’s right to choose” and highlighted her vote in favour of in favour of imposing Europe’s most extreme abortion laws on Northern Ireland. 

In the same questionnaire, Long-Bailey claimed she would “never contemplate abortion” but has since then tweeted about her “unequivocal support” to a host of pro-abortion pledges listed in an open letter to Labour’s leadership candidates. She tweeted: “For the avoidance of doubt, I unequivocally support this. Some pretty grubby attempts over the past 24 hours to deliberately misrepresent my position”.

She has been absent from most votes on abortion since her election, in 2015. 

That same year, she joined a majority of 212 MPs in voting against a Bill to introduce assisted suicide, in the UK, in 2015. 

The 40-year-old MP for Wigan gained 31 nominations from fellow MPs and MEPs. 

Under Jeremy Corbyn, Lisa Nandy initially stayed in the shadow cabinet as an energy spokeswoman, but later resigned in protest at his leadership, saying he was “unable to form a broad, inclusive shadow cabinet that draws on the best of our movement’s left and right traditions”.

Lisa has remained relatively quiet on abortion since becoming an MP in 2010, but her voting record displays her pro-abortion stance. Additionally, yesterday, she tweeted her full support to a host of pro-abortion pledges listed in an open letter to Labour’s leadership candidates. 

Lisa has voted against an explicit ban on sex-selective abortion, against mandating abortion clinics to offer free independent counselling and to impose an extreme abortion law in Northern Ireland. 

Lisa missed the vote on Rob Marris’ assisted suicide bill, which was defeated. 

The 38-year-old Birmingham Yardley MP secured 23 nominations to make the current contest round – just one above the threshold. 

In the same article, she attacked pro-life Conservative MP Maria Caulfield for wanting to start a debate on reducing the time limit on abortion to 12 weeks.

Jess celebrated Westminster’s decision to impose Europe’s most extreme abortion law on Northern Ireland, telling BBC Radio 1 Newsbeat: “We’re not doing this as Westminster overlords. We are doing it because hundreds and hundreds of women from Northern Ireland have requested that we fight for their rights.”

In 2017, she voted to introduce abortion on demand, for any reason, up-to-birth in England and Wales.

Jess Phillips also voted in favour of Rob Marris’ defeated assisted suicide bill. 

The 59-year-old shadow foreign secretary was the first contender to throw her hat into the ring, but the last to get enough nominations – making 23 just 10 minutes before the voting closed. 

Emily Thornberry has voted against an explicit ban on sex-selective abortion, against mandating abortion clinics to offer free independent counselling and against a law requiring parents of girls 15 and under are notified if their daughter is seeking an abortion.

Like all other leadership candidates, Emily voted last year to impose an extreme abortion law in Northern Ireland. Unlike other candidates, there is evidence of Emily backing the imposition of abortion laws on the province as far back as 2008. 

Emily Thornberry was absent in 2015 for the vote on Rob Marris’ rejected assisted suicide bill. 

How the leaders will be decided

  • 13 January: Nomination period closes
  • 15 January – 14 February: Second stage of nominations from Constituency Labour Parties and affiliates, including unions
  • 18 January: The first of seven scheduled hustings takes place in Liverpool
  • 20 January: Voting eligibility for new Labour Party members and affiliated supporters is frozen
  • 16 February: The last scheduled hustings is held in London
  • 21 February: Ballot opens for leadership candidates
  • 2 April: Ballot closes
  • 4 April: Special conference to announce results

Labour leader candidate attacked for opposing abortion up to birth for Down’s syndrome

A Labour leadership candidate has come under attack from the party’s supporters on social media after it was revealed she does not support disability-selective abortion after the standard limit of 24 weeks.

Currently, disability-selective abortion, for conditions including Down’s syndrome, cleft lip is legal for any reason up to birth while the upper limit is 24 weeks if the baby has no disability. 

Rebecca Long-Bailey confirmed her position in her response to a series of questions from representatives of Salford’s Catholic cathedral during the 2019 election campaign. 

A spokesman for Long-Bailey has since ‘stressed’ to the Guardian that she “unequivocally supports a woman’s right to choose” and highlighted her vote in favour of in favour of imposing Europe’s most extreme abortion laws on Northern Ireland.

Asked by priests at Salford Cathedral if she would support the removal of this clause, Long-Bailey said:

“I personally do not agree with this position and agree with the words of the Disability Rights Commission that ‘the context in which parents choose whether to have a child should be one in which disability and non-disability are valued equally.’”

Criticism of Long-Bailey’s views fly in the face of public opinion and have been highlighted by international regulatory bodies. 

In 2017, UK polling found that the majority now feel that disability should not be a grounds for abortion at all, with only one in three people thinking it is acceptable to ban abortion for gender or race but allow it for disability.

The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC, previously the Disability Right Commission) have said: “The Section is offensive to many people; it reinforces negative stereotypes of disability… is incompatible with valuing disability and non-disability equally”.

The UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities has consistently criticised laws which differentiate between unborn babies on grounds of disability.

These concerns were also noted in a UK Initial Report on the CRPD, which stated under Article 10 – the right to life – “concerns were expressed around the approach to abortion in the UK, where disabled people have suggested a bias towards termination of pregnancies if a child is likely to be disabled”.

In 2013 a parliamentary inquiry into abortion for disability found the vast majority of those who gave evidence believed allowing abortion up to birth on the grounds of disability is discriminatory, contrary to the spirit of the Equality Act 2010 and affects wider public attitudes towards discrimination. The inquiry recommended Parliament reviews the question of allowing abortion on the grounds of disability and should consider repealing section 1(1)(d) of the Abortion Act which allows for it.

Lord Shinkwin, who has been disabled since birth, sought to change the legal limit for all terminations to 24 weeks in 2017 but his private member’s bill, which was supported by Disability Rights UK, ran out of time before progressing beyond the House of Lords.

Responding to a question on the 24-week time-limit for abortion and whether it should be reduced, Long-Bailey said that the Labour Party would consult on any changes to abortion regulations and that she would “play her part” in “ensuring that [the Catholic Church’s pro-life] views are heard.”

In the same questionnaire, Long-Bailey claimed she would “never contemplate abortion” but did reinstate Labour’s manifesto promise to “uphold women’s reproductive rights and decriminalise abortions.” 

She also indicated she would be supportive of ending maternity discrimination and would ban the unfair dismissal of pregnant women. “Labour will also revolutionise parents’ rights by increasing paid maternity leave from nine to 12 months, doubling paternity leave to four weeks and extending pregnancy protection,” she added.

While she has been absent from most other votes on abortion since she was first elected, in 2015, Long-Bailey voted in favour of imposing Europe’s most extreme abortion laws on Northern Ireland. 

In 2015, she joined a majority of 212 MPs in voting against a Bill to introduce assisted suicide in the UK. 

Long-Bailey is standing against Sir Keir Starmer, Lisa Nandy, Jess Philipps, Emily Thornberry. She received the second-highest number of nominations, with the backing of 33 Labour colleagues.

Jeremy Corbyn’s successor will be announced on 4 April. He is standing down after Labour lost its fourth general election in a row last month, suffering their worst electoral defeat since 1935. 

It comes after the party pledged plans to introduce abortion, for any reason, up to birth. 

Sadly, all five leadership candidates voted in favour of imposing Europe’s most extreme abortion law on Northern Ireland.

Our analysis will be published in full tomorrow. 

A spokesperson for Right To Life UK, Catherine Robinson said:

“It’s ridiculous to see outrage against a leadership candidate simply stating that they oppose aborting babies with conditions such as cleft lip, club and Down’s syndrome right through to birth. This is a mainstream position with strong support from disability rights groups and the wider population. 

“Polling shows that the majority of people feel that disability should not be a grounds for abortion at all. This demonstrates that the small but vocal group of people who are outraged about Rebecca Long Bailey’s position on disability abortion are totally out of touch.”